Immigration Economics

Support Research for Balanced Immigration Policy in Canada

Join us in shaping Canada’s economic future. Our think tank is seeking funding for research on immigration’s impact on wages, housing, and productivity to create fair, evidence-based policies. Your donations fund critical studies that ensure immigration benefits all Canadians. Be part of the solution—please support our work resolving the following issues.

Donate Now

 

Inflationary Pressures

• Housing Demand Surge: High immigration levels drive up demand for housing, especially in cities like Toronto and Vancouver, reducing affordability relative to wages.
• Broader Cost Increases: Rapid population growth outpaces supply adjustments, raising costs in healthcare and education, contributing to overall inflation.
• Example: In the Greater Toronto Area, millions of new immigrants have been linked to shelter inflation, impacting consumer prices.

Negative Impact on Productivity

• Lower Capital Intensity: Large inflows of lower-skilled immigrants lead businesses to rely on abundant labour rather than investing in technology.
• Masked Inefficiencies: Under-counting immigrants in labour statistics can inflate measured productivity, hiding inefficiencies.
• Long-Term Effects: Shifts toward low-productivity sectors like retail slow innovation and economic efficiency.

Adverse Effects on the Labour Market

• Wage Suppression: High immigration increases labour supply, reducing wages by 3-4% for every 10% rise in immigrant workers in fields like construction or services.
• Displacement: Canadian-born workers, including less-educated ones in areas across Canada, face reduced job opportunities.
• Inequality: Employers favouring cheaper immigrant labour widen income gaps.

Suppression of Fertility Rates

• Economic Uncertainty: Competition for jobs and housing in high-cost regions like British Columbia delays family formation among native-born Canadians.
• Housing Strain: Immigrants occupying housing in cities like Calgary or Montreal limit options for families, discouraging childbirth.
• Resource Pressure: Increased competition strains infrastructure, adding to economic challenges.

Native-Born Canadians Lose

• GDP vs. Per Capita: Immigration boosts GDP, but benefits mainly go to immigrants via wages, with little net gain for native-born Canadians.
• Wealth Redistribution: Wage suppression and capital owner gains provide minimal aggregate benefit to native-born workers.

Exasperating Inequalities

• Resource Strain: High immigration without integration policies overburdens healthcare and housing in provinces like Ontario and British Columbia.
• Economic Disparities: Wealthier groups benefit from cheaper labour, while poorer Canadian workers face reduced per capita growth.

Challenges

• Fiscal Burdens: Large immigrant cohorts increase spending on social programs like Employment Insurance and infrastructure without immediate tax revenue.
• Integration Issues: Cultural and skill mismatches prolong dependency, straining provincial services.
• Social Tensions: Rapid demographic shifts in areas like Greater Vancouver risk political and social instability.

Possible Solutions

• Selective Immigration: Pause most immigration while prioritizing skilled workers or temporary residents to complement the Canadian workforce.
• Workforce Training: Invest in training native-born Canadians for high-demand fields like technology or trades to boost productivity.
• Housing Policies: Accelerate construction incentives in provinces like Manitoba or Quebec to ease demand-driven inflation.

Conclusion

While the economic effects of Canadian immigration remain debated, more rigorous, longitudinal research is essential to inform evidence-based policies and solutions that align with Canada’s economic and social goals. Continued research is critical to crafting policies that balance economic growth with fairness for all Canadians. We can’t do it without you—your donations make this vital work possible.

See what we’re doing about this (Capacity Index)

See what we’re doing about this (US Policies)